The pros and cons of setting up an SMSF in Australia

Anshu Lukka
Anshu Lukka 8 min read  ·  Published 20 November 2026
Share
Pros and cons of SMSF

A self-managed super fund (SMSF) gives you direct control over your retirement savings. You choose the investments, decide when to buy and sell, and can pool super with family or business partners. But you also become the trustee, which means you’re personally responsible for every decision and for keeping the fund compliant with strict super laws.

So is setting up an SMSF worth it? That depends on your balance, your goals, and how much time you are willing to commit. In this blog, we break down the main pros and cons of setting up an SMSF in Australia, including the 2026 changes to property borrowing. We also look at who an SMSF suits best, and walk through the seven steps to set one up.

Key takeaways

  • An SMSF gives you direct control, but you become the trustee and are personally responsible.
  • An SMSF can hold property, shares, term deposits, and collectables that align with your investment strategy.
  • Up to six members can pool super to boost buying power and share costs.
  • The fund pays up to 15% tax on earnings, and you control when to sell assets.
  • Fixed costs often run $1,500 to $6,000 or more a year, favouring larger balances.
  • Breaches of compliance rules can lead to personal fines, frozen assets, or disqualification.

What does setting up an SMSF mean?

Setting up an SMSF means you create your own super fund and take charge of it, instead of leaving your super with a large industry or retail fund. In practice, it means three things:

  • You create a legal fund. The fund is a trust, established under a trust deed that sets out its rules.
  • You become the trustee. Every member is a trustee (or a director of a corporate trustee), so you make the investment decisions and are personally responsible for keeping the fund compliant.
  • You move your super across. Once the fund is registered with the ATO and has its own bank account, you roll your existing super into it.

The process typically takes 4 to 5 weeks, and the steps must be completed in the right order to keep the fund compliant.

SMSF pros and cons at a glance

Here’s a quick snapshot of the main pros and cons of setting up an SMSF in Australia, so you can see the big picture before we explore each point in detail.

Pros

  • Investment control

    Property, shares and term deposits to match your strategy

  • Pooled balances

    Up to 6 members share buying power and costs

  • Tax flexibility

    Earnings taxed up to 15%, and you choose when to sell

  • Cost-efficiency as you grow

    Fixed fees shrink as a share of a larger balance

  • Estate planning

    Binding nominations and reversionary pensions

Cons

  • Compliance and liability

    You are the trustee. Breaches can mean fines or frozen assets

  • Time and admin

    Audit, tax return, strategy reviews, record-keeping

  • No free dispute resolution

    Members generally can’t go to AFCA

  • Fixed costs

    Roughly $1,500 to $6,000+ a year, tough on small balances

  • Insurance

    Group cover usually lost, replacement premiums can be higher

  • Moving overseas

    Can put the fund’s tax concessions at risk

Often suits larger balances ($250,000+) and hands-on investors. Get advice before you decide.

What are the pros of setting up an SMSF?

The main pros of setting up an SMSF are broader asset and investment control, the ability to pool balances with family or business partners, greater control over tax timing, fixed running costs that become more cost-effective as your fund grows, and flexible estate planning. Here is a detailed breakdown of these five key advantages.

Greater investment control and asset choice

Many people set up an SMSF because it lets them shape their investments around their own long-term goals rather than choosing from a fund’s preset menu. Depending on your investment strategy and the law, an SMSF can hold:

  • Direct residential or commercial property
  • Listed shares and term deposits
  • Unlisted companies
  • Collectables such as art and physical gold

An SMSF can also borrow to buy property through a limited recourse borrowing arrangement (LRBA), something most other fund types don’t offer. The rules changed in 2026:

  • New residential LRBAs are banned. The ban applies from 10 August 2026, while existing arrangements are grandfathered.
  • Business property is still allowed. LRBA borrowing remains available for commercial and business real property.
  • Residential property can still be bought outright. An SMSF can acquire it without borrowing, subject to the usual super rules.

This freedom has firm limits. Property generally can’t be purchased from a related party or lived in by a member, and collectables are subject to strict storage, insurance and personal-use rules. LRBAs come with tight conditions and additional costs, and the ATO has cautioned trustees against overinvesting and overborrowing in property.

Above all, every investment must be consistent with your fund’s written investment strategy.

Pooling super with family or partners

A self-managed super fund (SMSF) can have up to six members, so couples, relatives, or business partners can combine their super into one portfolio. This brings two main benefits:

  • Greater buying power. A larger combined balance allows the fund to buy assets, such as commercial property, that no single member could afford on their own.
  • Shared costs. Fixed expenses such as SMSF accounting, auditing, and administration are split among members, lowering the cost per person.

The downside is concentration risk. If the fund allocates a large share of its money to a single asset and that asset performs poorly, every member is affected. Even with pooled funds, it’s important to spread investments across different asset types.

Tax planning flexibility

Super is taxed at lower rates than normal income, and an SMSF gets the same low rates as any other super fund.

  • While you are building your super, the fund pays tax of up to 15% on its investment earnings. Your own income tax can be as high as 45%.
  • After you retire: The fund can pay no tax on earnings from the money used to pay your pension, up to a limit.
  • After age 60: Money you take out of super is generally tax-free.

What an SMSF adds is more say over your tax. For example, you choose when to sell an investment, so you can pick a time that suits you. In a big fund, the fund makes those choices for you.

A new rule for people with very large balances: From 1 July 2026, people with more than $3 million in super pay extra tax on part of their earnings. This counts all your super, not just your SMSF. Most people have less than $3 million, so most won’t be affected.

Greater cost-efficiency as your SMSF grows

Thanks to advances in accounting technology and increased competition among service providers, SMSFs have become a far more cost-effective option across a wider range of balances.

Unlike retail and industry super funds, which typically charge administration and investment fees as a percentage of your total balance, most SMSF operational costs (such as annual accounting, tax returns, independent audits, and the ATO supervisory levy) are fixed.

As your fund's balance grows, these fixed fees become proportionally smaller, allowing you to retain a greater share of your investment returns over time.

Want more of your money working for your retirement?

Book a call with our SMSF team and let’s build a cost-effective fund from day one.

Schedule a call

All packages

SMSF setup and accounting packages

Fees quoted below are GST exclusive

Cancel anytime Unlimited support Quick onboarding

Individual trustee set up

One-off payment
From
$450
*ex GST
Enquire now

Flexible estate planning

SMSFs can offer more control over what happens to your super when you die. A well-drafted trust deed can allow:

  • Binding death benefit nominations, including non-lapsing ones
  • Reversionary pensions, so a pension continues to a chosen dependant
  • Cascading nominations, or the exclusion of certain beneficiaries

These tools let you set out who should receive your benefits and keep your family in control of how they are paid.

There are limits. Death benefits can generally only be paid to eligible dependants or to your legal personal representative (your estate), so they can’t go directly to a family trust.

The deed must be drafted correctly and kept up to date, and family disputes can still complicate things. Good planning improves the odds of a smooth outcome, but it doesn’t guarantee one.

What are the cons of setting up an SMSF?

The main cons of setting up an SMSF include personal liability for strict compliance rules, significant time and paperwork demands, limited dispute resolution options, fixed running costs that can erode smaller balances, higher personal insurance premiums, and potential tax penalties if you move overseas.

Here is a detailed breakdown of these six challenges.

Heavy compliance burden and personal liability

When you run your own super fund, you are legally responsible for everything it does, including every investment decision. A poor investment can reduce the fund’s assets, and that affects every member’s retirement balance.

Every SMSF must also comply with the sole purpose test, which means the fund must exist solely to provide retirement benefits to members. That rules out taking your super early or using the fund for personal benefit, such as paying a private bill from the fund’s bank account.

Super law is complex, and the ATO polices it closely. Penalties for breaches can include loss of the fund’s concessional tax treatment, trustee disqualification, frozen assets, and fines or even criminal proceedings in serious cases.

  • Personal fines. The ATO can issue penalties to individual trustees or corporate trustee directors. These are generally your own responsibility, and the fund can’t pay them for you.
  • Higher tax. A complying SMSF pays tax on earnings at up to 15%, and a non-complying fund can be taxed at the top rate of 45%. In some cases, this can also apply to the value of the fund’s assets.
  • Frozen assets. In serious cases, the fund’s bank accounts and investments can be frozen, which stops you from buying, selling, or moving money.
  • Disqualification. Serious or repeated breaches can lead to a trustee being disqualified from acting as an SMSF trustee.

Significant time commitment and administration workload

Running an SMSF requires active, hands-on management; it is not a set-and-forget retirement account. Every financial year, trustees must arrange an independent audit and lodge an SMSF annual return, alongside managing several ongoing operational duties:

  • Investment strategy management: Formulate, document, and regularly review a tailored investment strategy that accounts for risk, diversification, liquidity, and the insurance needs of all members.
  • Strict record-keeping: Maintain accurate books of accounts and detailed minutes of all trustee decisions, with certain statutory documents required to be kept for up to 10 years.
  • Member reporting: Provide clear, regular updates to all fund members on the SMSF's financial position and performance.
  • Regulatory monitoring: Stay up to date with frequent changes to Australian superannuation and tax laws to avoid inadvertent breaches.

For busy professionals and business owners, these ongoing obligations can quickly become overwhelming. That is where CleanSlate steps in.

Our SMSF accounting team handles the setup of your fund, whether under an individual or corporate trustee structure, manages its day-to-day administration, maintains your accounting records, and prepares and lodges your annual tax returns and compliance reports. You retain full control over your investment decisions while we manage the paperwork that keeps your fund compliant.

No access to free external dispute resolution

Members of public super funds can take a complaint about their fund to an external dispute resolution service, such as the Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA). SMSF members generally can’t, because the members are also the trustees. SMSF members don’t have access to conflict resolution services and must manage their own disputes.

This matters if members disagree, for example:

  • Over how the fund should invest
  • Over what happens when a member leaves or a relationship breaks down
  • Over who receives a member’s benefits after they die

If the members can’t agree, the options are usually mediation or the courts, and legal action can be slow and costly. Those costs come out of the fund, which reduces everyone’s retirement savings.

Fixed costs can hurt returns on smaller balances

Most industry and retail funds charge fees that are largely based on your balance. As discussed above, many SMSF costs are fixed, so the audit and ATO levy are the same whether your fund holds $200,000 or $2 million. That favours large balances and can hurt small ones.

The main costs are:

  • Setup: a one-off cost to create the fund. This includes the trust deed (the legal document that sets out the fund’s rules) and, optionally, a company to act as trustee instead of individual members. A company costs more to set up but can make the fund easier to manage.
  • Annual independent audit: Required every year.
  • ATO supervisory levy: Currently $259 a year, and $518 in the first year (a proposed increase to $295 has been announced).
  • Accounting and tax returns: Usually handled by an accountant or administrator, and they cost more for complex funds.
  • ASIC review fee: If you use a corporate trustee.
  • Extras: Asset valuations, legal fees, insurance, interest on borrowing, and investment advice.

Together, these often come to roughly $1,500 and $6,000 or more a year, depending on the fund’s assets and how much work you outsource. On a small balance, that takes a big slice of your returns.

A common rule of thumb is that an SMSF becomes cost-effective at around $250,000, especially if you do much of the admin yourself. It is not a fixed rule, and the right figure depends on your situation.

Loss of group insurance and higher cover costs

If you roll your whole balance out of an industry or retail fund into an SMSF, any life, Total and Permanent Disability (TPD) or income protection cover attached to your old account usually ends. Replacing it inside an SMSF has some drawbacks:

  • Higher premiums: Large funds negotiate discounted group rates, whereas an SMSF buys individual retail policies, which are often more expensive.
  • Medical underwriting: Large funds often accept you automatically, but SMSF policies usually require health checks. Pre-existing conditions can lead to higher premiums, exclusions or a refusal of cover.
  • Trustee responsibility: You must consider each member's insurance needs when setting the fund’s investment strategy, and organise and manage the policies yourself.

Arrange replacement cover before closing your old account, so you’re never left uninsured during the transition.

Moving overseas can put your fund at risk

An SMSF must stay an “Australian superannuation fund” to keep its tax concessions. Among other things, the trustees’ main decisions about the fund must ordinarily be made in Australia.

A temporary absence of up to two years is generally allowed, but moving overseas permanently can put the fund at risk. Contributing to the fund while you are living overseas can also cause problems, depending on where the other members live. If the fund fails these tests, it can lose its concessional tax treatment and face much higher tax. Get advice before you move.

Is it worth setting up an SMSF?

There is no legislated minimum balance to start an SMSF, so whether it is worth it comes down to a simple trade-off: does the control you gain outweigh the cost, time, and legal responsibility you take on?

Rather than looking at each pro and con in isolation, it helps to see which type of investor actually benefits from running their own fund.

Who is an SMSF best suited for?

You are most likely to benefit from running your own fund if you fit one or more of these profiles:

  • People with higher balances (often $250,000 or more combined). Once your pooled balance is large enough, the fund’s fixed costs can work out lower than the percentage-based fees of a retail or industry fund. This is a rule of thumb, not a fixed line.
  • Business owners and hands-on investors. If you want to hold your business premises inside super, or follow a specific investment strategy that a standard public fund doesn’t offer, an SMSF gives you the freedom to do that.
  • Families with detailed estate or tax goals. If planning retirement income, timing capital gains and controlling how death benefits are paid matters a lot to you, an SMSF gives you more control over each of these than most public funds. The rules still apply, so good advice and a well-drafted trust deed are essential.

Who is usually better off in an industry or retail fund?

A public super fund is generally a better fit if your situation looks more like this:

  • People still building their super balance. If your balance is modest and you aren’t making large ongoing contributions, a fund with percentage-based fees keeps your costs low while your savings grow.
  • Time-poor or set-and-forget investors. If you want solid long-term returns without annual audits, trustee records and personal legal responsibility for compliance, a good public fund takes that off your plate.
  • People who may move overseas or rely on group insurance. Moving overseas can put an SMSF’s tax concessions at risk, and replacing group cover inside an SMSF usually means higher premiums and medical checks. Staying in a public fund avoids both problems.

How to set up an SMSF: The 7 steps at a glance

To set up an SMSF, you must establish a legal trust, register the fund with the Australian Taxation Office (ATO), open a dedicated bank account, and roll over your existing super via SuperStream. The process typically takes 4 to 5 weeks and must follow this exact sequence to stay compliant:

  1. Engage an SMSF specialist

    Look for an SMSF accountant or administrator with hands-on SMSF experience, ideally registered with the Tax Practitioners Board. They can prepare the fund’s paperwork, handle its registration, and keep it compliant year to year.

  2. Create your trust deed

    This is the legal document that governs the fund's members, investments, benefit payments, and winding up.

  3. Appoint trustees and sign the ATO declaration

    All trustees must sign within 21 days. Disqualified persons can’t act as trustees.

  4. Register for an ABN and TFN

    Apply for the fund’s Australian Business Number (ABN) and Tax File Number (TFN) within 60 days of setting up the fund.

  5. Open a dedicated SMSF bank account

    It must be in the fund’s name and kept separate from all personal assets.

  6. Draft your investment strategy

    This is required before your first investment, and it must cover risk, return, liquidity, and diversification.

  7. Roll over your existing super

    The transfer is arranged through SuperStream. You will give your old fund the SMSF’s ABN, Electronic Service Address (ESA), and bank account details.

Want the full details on each step? Check out our blog, How to Set Up an SMSF in Australia, for a step-by-step explanation, including timeframes, costs, and common mistakes to avoid.

SMSF pros and cons FAQs

It can be, mainly because the risk sits with you rather than a professional trustee. Public funds spread money across many assets and employ investment teams. In an SMSF, a concentrated portfolio, a poor decision or a compliance slip falls on the members. SMSFs also generally don’t qualify for government compensation if money is lost to fraud or theft, which public funds regulated by APRA may.

Yes. You aren’t required to roll over your whole balance. Many people keep part of their super in an industry or retail fund and move the rest into an SMSF. This lets you keep existing insurance cover and reduces your reliance on a single fund, though you’ll still pay the SMSF’s running costs.

There’s no legal requirement, but you need to understand your duties as a trustee, including acting in the members’ best interests and keeping the fund separate from your personal finances. You can use accountants, administrators and licensed advisers, but you remain legally responsible for the fund’s decisions. If you are unsure, the ATO offers free trustee education resources.

Be cautious if someone is pressuring you to set one up quickly, promising early access to your super, or steering you toward one specific investment. Also reconsider if you wouldn’t be comfortable handling compliance tasks and trustee responsibilities, or if you are mainly motivated by a single property purchase. Always seek advice from a licensed adviser and check credentials on the ASIC register.

You can wind it up and move the balance to a public fund, but it isn’t instant. Assets must be sold or transferred in line with the rules, and a final audit and tax return are required. Costs and delays vary with the fund’s assets, so avoid setting up an SMSF as a short-term experiment.

It can offer flexibility, such as timing contributions around your income and cash flow, within contribution cap limits. But the fund’s expenses and compliance obligations continue regardless of your income. If your earnings fluctuate, make sure the fund can cover its fixed costs in lean years.

It’s strongly worth it. A licensed financial adviser can assess your goals, balance, risk tolerance and insurance needs, and an SMSF specialist accountant can explain the ongoing obligations and costs. Getting advice first costs far less than unwinding a fund that was a poor fit.

Final thoughts on the pros and cons of setting up an SMSF

An SMSF puts you in charge of your retirement savings, along with the legal duties that come with it. The upside is real: wider investment choices, tax-planning flexibility, pooled family balances, and tailored estate planning. The risks are real too—including personal liability, strict ATO compliance rules, and fixed running costs.

The good news is that you don’t have to carry the compliance load alone. Our SMSF accounting team handles your fund’s administrative setup, ongoing bookkeeping support, annual financial statements preparation, independent audit coordination, and SMSF annual returns—keeping your fund compliant so you can stay focused on your investment decisions.

Want an SMSF without the paperwork headaches? Get in touch with our team today to discuss your SMSF setup and ongoing accounting needs, and get started with confidence.

Anshu Lukka
Written by

Anshu Lukka

Director, CleanSlate Accounting Services

Anshu works with Australian SMSF trustees and small business owners on SMSF setup, accounting, compliance management, tax returns and financial statements, keeping funds fully aligned with ATO requirements.

We're here to help

CleanSlate – An innovative accounting firm who can help your business grow

Book a meeting

Need expert advice for your SMSF or financial goals? Schedule a meeting with our professional today.

Book a meeting

Call us

For urgent matters that can't wait, please call us right away.

1800 96 50 90

Send a message

If you have any questions or concerns, please leave a message.

Send message

Insights

Related SMSF blogs

Explore more of our SMSF guides, from setting up a fund to understanding fees, accounting services and compliance.

Partners

Our associates

Associate 1
Associate 2
Associate 3
Associate 4
Associate 5
Associate 6
Associate 7