How does negative gearing work in SMSF?
Have you been exploring ways to reduce your tax bill and grow your SMSF property portfolio? Negative gearing could be the answer, but do you fully understand how it works within an SMSF?
With its potential to offer tax advantages, negative gearing can seem like an attractive option. However, the rules around SMSFs are more complex than individual property investments, and getting it wrong could affect your retirement plans.
In this blog, we will answer key questions: What exactly is negative gearing in an SMSF? How does it compare to individual negative gearing? And how can you use it strategically to maximise tax benefits while minimising risks? So, read the complete blog to learn how to make the most of this strategy.
Key takeaways
SMSFs do not receive the 50 percent CGT discount available to individuals.
Complying SMSFs can access a one third CGT discount on assets held for more than twelve months.
Capital gains in a fully pension phase SMSF may be completely exempt under ECPI rules.
SMSF CGT can be taxed at 45 percent if the gain is treated as non arm’s length income.
Incorrect asset valuations or related party transactions can create NALI risks.
What is negative gearing in SMSF?
Negative gearing happens when the ongoing costs of holding an investment property are higher than the rental income the property generates. These costs commonly include:
- Loan interest
- Rates and water
- Insurance
- Property management fees
- Repairs and maintenance
- Depreciation
- Legal and accounting costs
When expenses exceed rental income, the property creates a financial loss. This loss becomes tax deductible because the property is held for the purpose of generating income.
Individuals often utilise negative gearing as a strategy to reduce their personal taxable income. Similarly, within an SMSF, a loss incurred on an investment property can reduce the tax liability of the fund. This is possible because SMSFs are taxed entities and can claim property-related expenses in the same way that individuals can for tax purposes.
Negative gearing is most effective when the property shows strong long-term capital growth potential, and when the trustee is prepared to sustain the shortfall until the property generates positive cash flow.
Fixed-fee SMSF setup and
accounting packages
Fees quoted below are GST exclusive
Cancel anytime
Unlimited support
Quick onboarding
How does negative gearing work inside an SMSF in Australia?
Negative gearing in SMSF works similarly to individual investments. However, there are specific rules for SMSFs in negative gearing as discussed below:
- Sole purpose test: The property purchase must align with the sole purpose of the SMSF, which is to provide retirement benefits to the fund members.
- Borrowing: SMSFs may only borrow using a Limited Recourse Borrowing Arrangement. This structure ensures that only the property itself is used as security. The SMSF cannot use any other assets as collateral.
- Separate property trust and custodian arrangement: Under an LRBA, the property is purchased through a separate custodian or holding trust. This ensures compliance if the fund defaults on the loan.
- All transactions must be at arm’s length: The SMSF must deal with third parties on commercial terms only. Rent, repayments and purchase contracts must reflect market conditions.
Understanding these rules is essential before proceeding with purchasing an investment property under an SMSF to ensure you are making informed decisions.
SMSF negative gearing vs individual negative gearing
When comparing negative gearing between SMSF and individuals, the main differences arise from SMSF taxation rules , fund access, and loan structures. The table below shows the comparison of SMSF negative gearing and individual negative gearing.
| SMSF negative gearing vs individual negative gearing | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Feature | SMSF negative gearing | Individual negative gearing | ||
| Tax rate | Fund income taxed at 15 percent | Up to 45 percent | ||
| Capital gains | 10 percent after 12 months | Fifty percent discount available | ||
| Cash flow benefits | Tax savings stay inside the fund | Immediate personal refund | ||
| Borrowing | LRBA only | Standard home loan | ||
| Contribution limits | Annual caps restrict funding | Unlimited personal funding | ||
| Use of property | No personal use allowed | Can be used personally if chosen | ||
| Compliance | Annual audits and strict rules | Lower compliance requirements | ||
Let's explore these aspects in detail to see how each option impacts investors.
Immediate tax relief and cash flow
Individual investors receive tax benefits more quickly. For example, if the property creates a negative cash flow of 10,000 and the investor is in a 30 percent tax bracket, they receive a tax refund of about 3,000.
This improves short-term cash flow. In contrast, SMSF tax benefits are limited to the fund itself and do not provide personal refunds. Members cannot access the tax savings until retirement.
Need expert help with SMSF accounting, tax, or audit management?
Book a call now
SMSF CGT tax rates at a glance
Understanding how CGT rates change inside an SMSF can be confusing, especially when compliance, holding periods, and pension phase rules all affect the final tax outcome. The table below provides a simple comparison of how each rule impacts the tax rate.
Loan structures and borrowing flexibility
SMSFs face tighter borrowing constraints. Under LRBA rules, lenders generally require:
- Larger deposits, typically 20 percent to 30 percent
- Higher interest rates
- Stricter lending criteria
- Extra legal structuring
Individuals can borrow up to 90 percent for investment properties and often receive lower interest rates. The complexity of SMSF property loans means that trustees must consider higher costs and limited refinancing options.
Contribution limits and restrictions
SMSFs depend on contributions to support negative cash flow, but contribution caps limit how much can enter the fund. Exceeding caps results in penalties.
Individual investors do not face such restrictions. They can use personal funds, redraw facilities, or equity to manage cash flow. This difference makes cash flow planning essential in SMSFs.
Investment strategy requirements
SMSFs must follow a documented investment strategy that is regularly reviewed. The strategy must consider:
- Risk tolerance
- Liquidity
- Insurance
- Expected returns
- Negative gearing impacts
- Diversification
Individuals have full flexibility to invest based on personal goals. SMSFs also undergo annual audits, adding compliance costs.
Property type restrictions
SMSFs face restrictions on the types of properties they can invest in. For example, they cannot buy property for personal use, such as holiday homes, and properties cannot be rented to related parties (e.g., family members), unless used for business purposes. In contrast, individual investors can buy any type of property, whether for personal use or investment, with no such restrictions.
Explore these helpful reads
Pros and cons of negative gearing in SMSFs
When using negative gearing in an SMSF, investors borrow funds to purchase property, with the expectation that the interest costs and other expenses will exceed the income generated by the property. This strategy may allow for tax deductions, but it also carries risks. Below, we explore the key benefits and drawbacks of negative gearing in SMSFs.
Pros
- Tax deductions: The costs associated with borrowing, such as interest payments, may be tax-deductible, potentially reducing the overall tax liability of the SMSF.
- Asset appreciation: If the property value increases over time, the SMSF can benefit from significant capital gains upon sale, even though the property was initially negatively geared.
Cons
- Risk of poor returns: If the property does not appreciate as expected, the SMSF may face long-term losses, as the borrowings must still be repaid regardless of the property's performance.
- Liquidity issues: Negative gearing may tie up a significant portion of the SMSF's funds in illiquid assets, leaving the fund vulnerable if it needs to access cash for other investments or liabilities.
The role of diversification in SMSF property investment
Relying heavily on a single negatively geared property increases risk. A diversified SMSF portfolio may include:
- Residential property
- Commercial property
- Managed funds
- Shares
- Cash and term deposits
Diversification protects the fund from market fluctuations and supports long term retirement stability.
Common mistakes trustees make with SMSF negative gearing
Trustees often face issues that could have been avoided with proper guidance. Common mistakes include:
- Buying property without reviewing the investment strategy
- Underestimating cash flow requirements
- Not understanding LRBA structures
- Renting to related parties
- Paying expenses personally instead of from the SMSF
- Poor documentation of arm’s length transactions
- Failure to maintain adequate diversification
Avoiding these mistakes protects the fund and supports compliance.
Avoid costly SMSF mistakes!
Strategies for maximising SMSF negative gearing potential
To fully take advantage of negative gearing within an SMSF, it’s important to implement strategies that maximise both cash flow and long-term returns. Here are some strategies to enhance the potential benefits of negative gearing in an SMSF:
1. Select properties with strong growth and yield potential
Properties with a balance of long-term growth and strong rental yield reduce the negative cash flow burden. Look for areas with stable rental demand, good infrastructure, economic growth and development forecasts. Properties offering renovation or upgrade potential can also increase valuations and rental income over time.
2. Leverage contributions to fund property investment
Contributions play a major role in SMSF negative gearing. Concessional contributions like salary sacrifice or employer payments help fund the property investment and reduce the SMSF’s taxable income. However, these are subject to annual caps (e.g., $30,000 for 2024-25).
Non-concessional contributions (after-tax) can also be used to boost property investment. The Bring-Forward Rule allows you to contribute up to three times the annual cap in one year, giving you more funds to invest in property. For example, in the 2025–26 financial year, you can contribute $360,000 if eligible.
By making the most of both concessional and non-concessional contributions, you can effectively support your SMSF’s property investments while managing tax obligations.
3. Keep track of all expenses for maximum tax benefits
Accurate tracking of property expenses ensures the SMSF receives every tax deduction it is entitled to. Expenses include:
- Loan interest
- Repairs and maintenance
- Property management fees
- Depreciation
- Legal fees
A quantity surveyor's report can maximise depreciation deductions
4. Reinvest tax savings to build a portfolio
Any tax savings or rental improvements can be reinvested into the SMSF to purchase additional assets. Over time, compounding growth from multiple properties can significantly increase retirement savings.
5. Regularly review investment strategy to stay compliant
The investment strategy must reflect changing market conditions, rental performance, loan repayments, and retirement goals. Reviewing it ensures ongoing compliance and alignment with long-term objectives.
How CleanSlate helps you optimise SMSF negative gearing?
Managing negative gearing inside an SMSF is complex, and getting it wrong can lead to penalties or missed tax outcomes. At CleanSlate, our SMSF accounting services for trustees ensure compliance and help you optimise property investments by:
- Identifying eligible property-related deductions
- Preparing financial statements, SMSF annual returns, and providing audit support
- Ensuring all investments follow ATO rules and documentation standards
With CleanSlate, you have an SMSF accounting and tax partner who helps keep your fund compliant and tax efficient while you build your retirement wealth.
SMSF and Negative Gearing FAQs
1. Can an SMSF negatively gear more than one property?
Yes. An SMSF can hold more than one negatively geared property if the fund has enough cash flow, complies with borrowing rules, and maintains a balanced investment strategy. The fund must show that multiple geared properties do not create liquidity risks.
2. Does negative gearing affect an SMSF’s ability to pay member benefits?
Yes. If too much of the fund is tied up in a negatively geared property, the SMSF may struggle to pay benefits, such as pensions or lump sums. Trustees must ensure the fund has enough liquid assets available at all times.
3. Does negative gearing impact the SMSF audit process?
Yes. The SMSF auditor will review loan documents, expense records, rent confirmations, and arm’s length conditions. Poor documentation or incorrect payments may lead to compliance issues. Learn more about SMSF record-keeping requirements.
4. Can negative gearing reduce the tax on SMSF concessional contributions?
No. Negative gearing does not reduce the 15% tax on concessional contributions. It only impacts the tax on the SMSF's investment income. By offsetting losses from negative gearing, it lowers the overall tax on the fund’s earnings.
5. Can an SMSF use rental guarantees for a negatively geared property?
Yes, but only if the guarantee is from an unrelated party. Guarantees from developers or related parties must be assessed carefully to ensure they meet arm’s length rules.
6. How does negative gearing affect SMSF exit strategies?
It may delay selling if the property is still cash flow negative or if the fund is waiting to enter the pension phase for tax benefits. Trustees need to plan exits early to avoid forced sales.
Final thoughts
Negative gearing within an SMSF can be an effective strategy to reduce tax, but it comes with complexities and risks. By understanding the benefits and complexities, you can leverage this strategy to build your retirement savings more effectively.
Navigating the intricacies of SMSF negative gearing requires careful planning and expert advice. At CleanSlate, we specialise in helping trustees maximise their tax benefits, ensure compliance, and optimise property investments. If you're ready to take the next step in optimising your SMSF, our team of experts is here to guide you every step of the way.
Book a call with our SMSF experts today. to start building a more secure retirement. We’re here to help you make the most of your SMSF strategy.
